Schiehallion – Contour lines and Maskelyne’s observatory

In 1774 large science was taking place in the heart of Scotland. Two men were about to weigh the earth. This was done using plumblines and measuring how much the hill in Perthshire, called Schiehallion, displaced them. Schiehallion was chosen for its uniform appearance and relative accessibility.

The two people responsible for the experiment were the astronomer Nevil Maskelyne and the surveyor Charles Hutton. Charles Hutton, in order to make calculations of the volume of the mountain, pioneered the use of contour lines. These were essential in joining up measurement points to create a continual observation. Maskelyne set up a cabin on each side of the mountain where he could live and take astronomical observations and plumbline readings. The hut on the north side of the mountain famously burned down during the whisky fuelled celebrations of completing the observations, taking with it a local boys precious fiddle. Upon returning to London Maskelyne compensated the boys loss by sending him a replacement fiddle, a Stradivarius.

A good account of the Scheihallion experiment can be found in Rachel Hewitt’s: Map of a Nation. Which also provides an excellent account of the early days of the Ordnance Survey.

My goal for the trip was to find the remains of Maskelyne’s ruined observatory, which according to some reports could still be found on the northern slopes of the mountain. The quest was inspired by Simon Ingram. Whose account of climbing Schiehallion in Between the Sunset and the Sea is definitely worth a read. I used the notes found in that book to narrow the search area.

Also available for free from Audible: Free 30 day trial

I set off, driving past Dull (Paired with Boring, Oregon), which was not a sign of how the day would turn out.

Dull and Boring

The first views of Schiehallion do not show the characteristic conical shape, rather a gradual slope.

First glimpse

However the uniformity can be seen in the historic Ordnance Survey maps:

UK Great Britain, Ordnance Survey one-inch to the mile (1:63,360), ‘Hills’ edition, 1885-1903 National Library of Scotland:

UK Great Britain, Ordnance Survey (1:1 million-1:10,560), 1900s from the National Library of Scotland:

UK Ordnance Survey Historical Maps from 1919-1947 National Library of Scotland:

UK Great Britain, Ordnance Survey One-Inch Seventh Series (1:63,360), 1955-1961 National Library of Scotland:

At the head of the car park there is a memorial to the observation work that took place on the hill.

Monument

Schiehallion from the car park (parking is £2, and only coins are accepted), with a suggestion of nice weather ahead.

Schiehallion

Unfortunately the weather in Scotland is never predictable. With hail one minute.

Hail

And sunshine the next.

Sun

View from the top of Schiehallion. My goal was to attain the summit, and on the way down break off from the path and head downslope.

Schiehallion

The remains of the Ordnance Survey trig point at the top of Schiehallion.

OS Trig Point

The view of the northern slope, so the observatory remains would be somewhere down there. There were a couple of promising piles of rocks that could be seen from up high, but upon closer inspection turned out to be… piles of rocks.

Slope

View back up to the ridge.

View back

Northern slope. The terrain was not difficult, but the weather was not ideal.

View down

I was just about the give up the search, but after climbing one final rise I saw a suspiciously uniform pile of rocks.

Finally

The remains of Maskelyne’s observatory. One platform was for the cabin, with the other one for the astronomical instruments.

Maskelyne's observatory

Backpack for scale.

Backpack

A job well done. The way back was very boggy. I took some solace in the fact that I was contouring around the hill that established contour lines. I was also spurred by the success of actually finding the site.

Happy Mapper

Final view back to Schiehallion.

View back

A successful journey, and excellent adventure.

If you want to visit the site I would recommend reading the description in Simon Ingram’s: Between the Sunset and the Sea, and baseing your own search on the description provided.

However I did track my own route, and I had been about to give up my own search before I finally found the site. So my route:

IMG_20151105_205557
As seen in Trail Magazines 2015 October issue-

X Percent of the Population of Scotland Lives Within Y Miles of Edinburgh

Follow up from the Glasgow post by request.

This is a pretty easy question to answer, using the 2011 Scottish Census population results and the Census Output Area Population Weighted Centroids. Then we get the extents of Edinburgh City Council from OS Boundary Line.

The results are:

,Pop. Count:,%
Scotland, 5295403, 100
Edinburgh , 476626, 9
25 km, 1276757, 24.1
50 km, 2500093, 47.2
50 miles, 3919910, 74
100 km, 4310869, 81.4
100 miles, 4812421, 90.9

So we see more than people live close to Glasgow, but with 50 miles + they are closer to the capital.

To see how these boundaries look on a map:

Population buffers around Edinburgh

A few caveats:
We are using the population weighted centroids, which will produce some minor inaccuracies, but is a very good generalisation.
Also we are using euclidean buffers on the British National Grid plain, so these are not geodesic buffers. The difference will likely be small at these distances.